Does the Nissan LEAF actually save you money?

Click to download spreadsheet
Quick Answer – Yes, if the cost of Gas is above $2.86 and the government offers incentives to the tune of $10,000.
If it wasn’t for the Government incentives, the financial case for the EV doesn’t add up. They are simply too expensive without the incentives right now. Hopefully costs will come down over time, the incentives won’t last forever.
How I compared the LEAF to an equivalent Gas vehicle.
There are a number of factors I considered in figuring out if it would make financial sense to purchase a Nissan LEAF instead of a gas vehicle.
- Fuel consumption of each vehicle – I used EPA “combined”numbers only.
- Cost of Fuel – Gas vs Electric. This is where the savings are.
- Free fill-ups – Stores have indicated they will offer free charging.
- Depreciation – LEAF costs more, so will depreciate more.
- Maintenance Costs – Fewer moving parts should mean lower costs.
- Capital Cost – Paying cash? The LEAF costs more so you have less money to invest.
- Financing Cost – Not paying cash? The LEAF’s higher price means higher interest payments.
- Insurance Cost – Nissan claim it’s cheaper to insure, I checked it out.
- Level 2 Charger Cost – Installing a charger in ones garage is recommended.
- Government Incentives – In Tennessee up to $10,000 is available.
- Taxes – The LEAF is pricey, so you pay more sales tax.
I created a spreadsheet to compare a similarly outfitted Nissan Versa against the LEAF and also the Chevy Volt. Feel free to download the Excel Spreadsheet. Continue reading →